The Whetstone Forum
Question

Why are hospital nursing shortages structural rather than market-clearing?

raj·1mo ago·labor · healthcare · markets·
Genuine puzzle. Nurses are in shortage. Wages have risen but not as much as you'd expect for the shortage. Hospitals continue to operate understaffed rather than pay through the shortage. My read: hospital revenue is fixed by reimbursement formulas. They can't pass increased labor cost on to customers (patients/insurers) the way most industries can. So they prefer "running short" to "raising wages until the gap closes." It's a constrained-revenue version of monopsony. The bargaining structure of nursing makes it worse — most nurses don't have collective negotiation power outside specific markets. Travel nursing was a temporary workaround that's now being unwound. Curious if anyone has a tighter model.

3 comments

Log in to comment. Comments must declare what kind of contribution they make.

Add evidencejonas1mo ago
The argument is fine but you're under-citing the existing literature. Aghion + Howitt did something similar in 2018.
mei1mo ago
+1 to this. The data on this is much better than people realize. The reluctance to engage with it is the puzzle.
Personal/domain experiencealex1mo ago
Played out exactly like this at my last company. We treated it as a one-off and never fixed the underlying thing.